Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson is a realistic fiction tale about alienation and it stresses the importance of communication and in standing up to injustice. The main character, Melinda, is raped at a party shortly before the beginning of her freshman year in high school. She calls the police but is unable to tell them what is wrong. Traumatized, she walks home. When the police arrive, she is not at the party and they arrest the party goers for underage drinking. Since Melinda was overheard calling the police, the students of her school blame her and she becomes a social pariah. As the year goes along, she progressively finds it harder and harder to speak – to anyone. Everything in her life becomes more difficult to deal with as she speaks less. Her grades go down, her only friend is a girl new to the school who cares more about being popular than in being a friend, she starts cutting class and her parents argue frequently. Her family and the school administrators don't understand that her behavior isn't just due to normal teenage moodiness and try punishment to resolve the problems.
Melinda is paralyzed by her despair until she does a report on woman's suffrage that includes a silent protest and, little by little, she begins to improve. Melinda begins to do yardwork, talking to her parents and even has a conversation with a girl she used to be friends with about her rapist's reputation. The girl tells her that "he's only after one thing, and if you believe the rumors, he'll get it, no matter what." She begins to realize that her silence enables her rapist to hurt other girls. She eventually has a confrontation with him which unleashes her anger and she is finally able to talk about what happened to her.
I really enjoyed this book. Even though she doesn't speak, Melinda has a constant commentary running in her head which is quite entertaining. Despite its dark subject matter, I didn't find the book depressing. I did feel Melinda's pain, though, especially when she is rejected by her only "friend". I would recommend this book to high school students, especially girls, the story is engrossing and the message important. Speak has received numerous accolades and awards including: ALA Best Book for Young Adults, Edgar Allan Poe Award finalist, IRA Young Adult Choice, Michael L. Printz Honor Book, National Book Award Finalist, New York Public Library Book for the Teen Age, New York Times Bestseller List, SCBWI Golden Kite Award, and YALSA Popular Paperback for Young Adults
Melinda's list of the first ten lies they tell you in high school would be a good hook. They are:
- We are here to help you.
- You will have time to get to your class before the bell rings.
- The dress code will be enforced.
- No smoking is allowed on school grounds.
- Our football team will win the championship this year.
- We expect more of you here.
- Guidance counselors are always available to listen
- Your schedule was created with your needs in mind.
- Your locker combination is private.
- These will be the years that you look back on fondly.

Your review made me want to read this book. I like your hook; from what I remember from high school that list is completely true. It is easy to relate to this girl because every reader is in high school and experiencing new things. I like that readers will get the message in this book that by speaking out, other people can be saved from that horrible experience.
ReplyDeleteThis book sounds very intense from your review. Did you find some parts of it difficult to read because of the pain Melinda was going through? Great hook, so true!
ReplyDeleteI can echo what Ashlee says - it sounds very intense. Do you think that this book would be an appropriate read for a victim of rape? Perhaps to give them courage to come forward, to let someone know?
ReplyDeleteI would only have this at the high school.
About recommending it to a victim of rape, it would really depend on the person.
ReplyDeleteI also liked your hook.
ReplyDeleteI remember that I read this book when the middle school librarian at Beavercreek wanted my opinion as to its appropriateness for the grade levels served. I found it very intense - not the rape scene which is not at all graphic - but because Melinda's pain seemed so real. We wound up leaving it in the middle school library (grades 6-8) because the standard review sources (School Library Journal and Booklist) both recommended it for ages 8-12.
This is a tough story. I have several students who have read this book and like it. And I agree with Dr. Berg, I think the intense feelings that students may feel at the emotional pain maybe a bit strong for younger readers. The story though sounds like it does give a voice to a situation that happens more than we would like to think.
ReplyDelete